Quote Originally Posted by openrangeowners View Post
I would not want to have my roof replaced if I saw a small hole like the OP. The eternabond will seal it permanently. Similar to a new car that received a stone chip on the front windshield the first week of ownership. Had it repaired because the risk of a leaking windshield after replacement is higher than leaving it alone. Van had 200,000 miles and the original windshield with the repair when I sold it (never cracked more and never leaked). Same with your roof - As soon as you have someone remove everything and replace it your chances of it leaking are higher versus if you repair it with eternabond (assuming it does not leak now).

If you do see something rub through the eternbond, remove it - although eternabond is much thicker than the roof membrane and the adhesive will keep the patch from moving or rubbing ....

For the future, maybe use a little bit of lap sealant and then cover with eternabond if something similar happens elsewhere. Bet it is a staple that worked its way loose or maybe a metal brace poking from the end of the roof truss?
The dealer removed the eternabond, cut a hole and added an attic vent yesterday. Very happy with the repair. Said it was a bent over staple that pushed it's way through. They also took pictures of the other sections where there is something underneath so that it is documented should I run into an issue in the future. This was all covered by GD under warranty. I was concerned about having the dealer replace the roof but if GD would have paid for Roof Armour I would have preferred that but I have read hear that they wouldn't do that for someone else that did need their roof replaced so I am happy with the approach that they took.

Rob